When we calculate cost basis for your Vanguard investments, we'll automatically use "average cost" for mutual funds and "first in, first out" for individual stocks. But you can change those settings—or use "specific identification" if you're more of a hands-on investor.
Here are some details to help you understand the pros and cons of each method.
| Pros | Cons | |
| Minimum Tax (MinTax) | Easy to use. This method automatically selects shares in an attempt to identify the most favorable tax rate for sales. | The shares with the most favorable tax rate might not be the shares with the lowest gains. Additionally MinTax does not prioritize appreciated shares when gifting. MinTax does not utilize tax advantageous strategies for transferring or gifting shares. MinTax may not minimize tax impact in every case and its effectiveness will vary depending on your individual circumstances. This method only considers the current transaction and the current taxable year. This method may not be the right approach depending on your long-term goals. |
| Specific identification (SpecID) | Provides the most flexibility for tax planning strategies. | Requires more effort: Generally you must specify the shares to be sold or transferred before the settlement date and Vanguard must confirm those specifications back to you within a reasonable time. |
| Highest in, first out (HIFO) | Maximizes losses and minimizes gains for tax purposes. | Doesn't consider holding period. May recognize short-term gains before long-term gains. |
| First in, first out (FIFO) | Easy to use. Sells first the shares for which we don't know the acquisition date, followed by the shares with the earliest acquisition date. | Sales and transfers are based on acquisition date and don't consider potential gains or losses. |
| Average cost (AvgCost) | Easy to use. This method averages the purchase price of your shares and bases the holding period on the earliest date the shares were acquired. | You must elect out of or into this method in writing. Upon the sale, transfer, or disposition of covered shares, you’ll be locked into the average cost method until you change it in writing. This may make certain tax planning, such as gifting or charitable giving, less advantageous. In limited circumstances, long-term gains or losses may be converted to short-term. |
Minimum Tax (MinTax)
Pros
Easy to use. This method automatically selects shares to result in the most favorable tax rate for sales.
Cons
The shares with the most favorable tax rate might not be the shares with the lowest gains. Additionally MinTax does not prioritize appreciated shares when gifting.
MinTax does not utilize tax advantageous strategies for transferring or gifting shares.
Specific identification (SpecID)
Pros
Provides the most flexibility for tax planning strategies.
Cons
Requires more effort: Generally you must specify the shares to be sold or transferred before the settlement date and Vanguard must confirm those specifications back to you within a reasonable time.
Pros
Maximizes losses and minimizes gains for tax purposes.
Cons
Doesn't consider holding period. May recognize short-term gains before long-term gains.
Pros
Easy to use. Sells first the shares for which we don't know the acquisition date, followed by the shares with the earliest acquisition date.
Cons
Sales and transfers are based on acquisition date and don't consider potential gains or losses.
Pros
Easy to use. This method averages the purchase price of your shares and bases the holding period on the earliest date the shares were acquired.
Cons
You must elect out of or into this method in writing. Upon the sale, transfer, or disposition of covered shares, you’ll be locked into the average cost method until you change it in writing. This may make certain tax planning, such as gifting or charitable giving, less advantageous. In limited circumstances, long-term gains or losses may be converted to short-term.
It's best to set your cost basis method immediately after you buy or acquire shares of a new investment. If you don't, when you sell shares of that investment, you'll have to pick a method before you can complete the transaction.
Even if you've already selected—and even used—one of these cost basis calculation methods, you can change it for future sales whenever you want.* And you can apply those changes to just one fund or to all the funds within an account. However, your new method will not automatically apply to any new investments that are added at a later time.
Log in to set or change your cost basis method
Changes to or from the average cost method can't be accepted by phone.
We offer four accounting methods:
You can select your method anytime during the calendar year and have it applied retroactively.
To select your accounting method, you must first request the appropriate form by calling us at 800-669-0514.
Once you've completed the form, mail it back by December 31 of the year for which the selections are made if you want those selections to be considered when Vanguard prepares your IRS Form 1099.
Additional resources
Prefer paper?
Download, complete & mail a Cost Basis Method Election Form (PDF)
*If average cost was previously used, the shares you acquired before the method change may be locked with the average basis. By law, to revoke the average basis, you must change your cost basis method before the first sale, transfer, or disposition.
This information isn't intended to be tax advice and can't be used to avoid any tax penalties. We recommend you consult a tax advisor.